A roof leak in Toms River rarely announces itself politely — it shows up as a ceiling stain after a bay-driven downpour or a pile of shingle tabs on the lawn after a nor’easter. We find the actual source (which is often several feet uphill from where the water shows inside), fix it right, and tell you the truth about whether the roof has years left or is telling you it’s time.
What we repair most in Toms River
Wind-lifted and missing shingles — common east of Hooper Avenue and out in Ortley Beach, re-secured to coastal spec so they hold next time
Chimney and wall flashing leaks — the number-one true source of “roof” leaks on Toms River’s 1970s–80s housing stock
Pipe boots and vent seals — cracked rubber boots are a cheap fix that saves an expensive ceiling
Valley and nail-pop leaks — from decades of freeze-thaw on older Holiday City and North Dover roofs
Emergency tarping — to stop an active leak today while we schedule the permanent repair
The diagnosis comes first
We don’t guess. We photograph the roof (drone where it helps), trace the water path, and show you what’s actually failing before we quote. If the honest answer is that a $1,200 repair only buys a year on a worn-out roof, we’ll say so and walk you through a full replacement and financing instead — no pressure either way.
Toms River Township requires permits on structural roof work; we handle that when a repair crosses into replacement territory. Not sure which camp you’re in? Our repair-vs-replacement guide lays out the math, or just call 848-633-6440 and we’ll take a look. Learn more about everything we do locally on our Toms River service page.
Homeowners on Paragon
Our neighbors say it best
“From the initial meeting with Joe and Frank, all the way through the completion of our new roof and chimney cap, the process was seamless. Their team is professional, showed up when they said, delivered on all deadlines and the clean up was impeccable. The workmanship and warranty far exceeded anything we were offered by the other roofing companies.”
Rob & Linda
Roof replacement
“We are extremely satisfied with the work done by Paragon Exteriors. Their team was professional, efficient, and the results exceeded our expectations.”
Dan Marone
Exterior renovation
“Professionalism, reliability, and excellence define the people at Paragon Exteriors. They transformed our roof with skill and precision.”
Lisa O'Neill
Roof replacement
A new roof, on a monthly payment that fits.
We offer flexible financing so storm damage or an aging roof never has to wait on a lump sum. Ask about current
plans when you book your free estimate.
Most Toms River roof repairs run $450–$1,800: a few lifted shingles or a pipe-boot leak sits at the low end, while chimney flashing rebuilds or larger wind damage in Silverton and Ortley Beach run higher. We quote the repair free and tell you honestly if a repair is throwing good money after bad.
Can you repair a roof leak the same day in Toms River?
Usually yes. Toms River is the center of our service area, so an active leak in Holiday City, Bayville-adjacent North Dover, or Ortley Beach can typically be tarped or patched the same day you call 848-633-6440. Send a photo of the ceiling stain and we triage on the spot.
Do wind repairs in Ortley Beach need special work?
Yes. Barrier-island and bayfront roofs lose shingles to uplift that inland roofs never see, so we re-secure with coastal six-nail fastening and reseal edges rather than just tucking the tab back down — a repair that survives the next nor’easter instead of reopening.
Should I repair or replace my Toms River roof?
If the roof is under ~15 years old with isolated damage, repair. If it is 20+ years old, shedding granules across whole slopes, or you have chased multiple leaks, replacement usually wins on 10-year cost. We give you the honest call — we do both, so we have no reason to push one.
Free estimate in Toms River
Tell us about your project — we respond fast, usually the same day.
Ready to protect your biggest investment?
Free estimates. Honest pricing. Craftsmanship that lasts.
